Differences in anticipated and actual gravity readings

I have noticed some trends in the gravity readings of my recent brews:

  • The Starting Gravity (SG) is normally within a couple of points of the anticipated SG. I think this is probably explained due to the slightly different volumes transferred into the FV.
  • The Final Gravity (FG), however, is always underneath the anticipated FG. I am not sure how much of a problem this is, but it does produce slightly stronger (ABV%) beer than expected.

BrewSG AntSG ActSG diffFG AntFG ActFG diffMash inYeastFerm days
3510601058-210121008-466WC8
3610531051-210131007-665LF10
3710521052010091009065S-0511
3810451047210101007-366S-0511
3910441044010081006-265S-0510
4010431045210111007-466WC8
4110371039210071005.5-1.565S-058
4210431042-110091006-366Notts7
4310411045410101007-366Notts7
4410391039010091005-466S-059
4510441043-110081003-565S-059
4610451045010101007-366S-0510

The table above contains the data for the last 12 brews. All of the brews are all grain recipes and the SG/FG calculated using the Grainfather app. I was interested in spotting any potential trends.

  • Lallemand Nottingham (“Notts” in the table above) yeast seems to complete fermentation the most quickly.
  • White Labs London Fog (“LF” in the table above) produced the biggest difference in Final Gravity. However, this brew required 2 packets of yeast rather than one. This might explain things, but I only have brewed using this once.
  • A mash in temperature of 66 rather than 65 seems to be more effective in lowering the FG readings.
  • Fermentis S-05 yeast seems to produce some pretty consistent results over a number of different brews.
  • It turns out brew number 45 had a wild yeast contamination hence the really low FG. See here for more details.
  • Those brews with the most marked difference in FG are where I have extended the 20C fermentation period because there is still a lot of activity in the FV. I wait until the fermentation is starting to slow before increasing the temperature to 23C. So this indicates that a more active fermentation leads to a lower FG. No surprise there then!